Senator John Heinz

RELATED NEWS

  • Elizabeth Kolbert's work on "The Sixth Extinction" is profiled by The Boston Globe go >>
  • Lynn Goldman pens opinion piece on air pollution and children for CNN go >>
  • Ann Hamilton to design a woven art installation for subway station damaged in 9/11 attack go >>
  • Robert Langer and his work is profiled in MIT's Technology Review go >>
  • Elizabeth Kolbert wins 2015 Pulitzer Prize for her new book, The Sixth Extinction go >>
  • Joel Salatin is profiled in The Washington Post go >>
  • Edward Zigler reflects on Head Start's 50th anniversary go >>
  • Sanjeev Arora and Project ECHO undertaking new initiative to treat TB patients in New Mexico go >>
  • Jane Lubchenco honored with the 2015 Tyler Prize for Environmental Achievement go >>
  • Dean Kamen is interviewed about his career as an inventor by The Washington Post go >>
  • Robert Langer is profiled on NPR’s From Scratch go >>
  • Amory Lovins appears on the Ed Show at MSNBC to discuss clean energy independence by 2050 go >>
  • Rick Lowe and Project Row Houses featured on PBS NewsHour go >>
  • Abraham Verghese is interviewed for Stanford Medicine's Spring Issue go >>
  • Janine Benyus’ Biomimicry 3.8 and Arizona State University launching a joint collaboration, the Biomimicry Center go >>
  • James Nachtwey honored with lifetime achievement award by American Society of Magazine Editors go >>
  • John Luther Adams' "Become Ocean" wins the best contemporary classical composition Grammy Award go >>
  • Mason Bates is scoring new film by Gus van Sant, The Sea of Trees go >>
  • Robert Langer recieves the £1 million Queen Elizabeth Award go >>
  • John Harbison's new work for violinist Jennifer Koh, "For Violin Alone," is reviewed by the New York Times go >>
  • Dan Sperling appointed the 2015 chair of the Transportation Research Board’s Executive Committee go >>
  • Khan Academy to launch LearnStorm, a math challenge for Bay Area Schools go >>
  • Marian Wright Edelman writes an Op Ed piece on child poverty for BillMoyers.com go >>
  • The Kennedy Center names Mason Bates as composer-in-residence go >>
  • Richard Jackson named as recipient of Notre Dame's 2015 Henry Hope Reed Award go >>
  • Rick Lowe is named 2015 Breeden Eminent Scholar Chair at Auburn University go >>
  • Mason Bates profiled on radio station WABE in Atlanta go >>
  • John Luther Adams is honored with Columbia Unversity's William Shuman Award for lifetime achievement go >>
  • Dean Kamen is profiled on CBS News Sunday Morning go >>
  • James Nachtwey photographs moments from the new movie "Selma" go >>
  • Jane Lubcheno named first U.S. Science Envoy for the Ocean go >>
  • Cary Fowler speaks to the New Scientist about the critical need for seed banks go >>
  • Mark di Suvero's Dreamcatcher sculpture coming to UCSF Mission Bay go >>
  • James Comer receives the Sidney Berman Award from the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry go >>
  • John Holdren, in his role as the President's science advisor, solicits questions via social media go >>
  • Mildred Dresselhaus the first woman to receive IEEE's highest award, the Medal of Honor go >>
  • Bruce Katz offers a commentary piece on "What the Rise of Retirees and Minorities Means for U.S. Business," in Fortune go >>
  • William Thomas and the Green House Project are profiled in a New York Times article go >>
  • Paul Farmer appears as a guest on The Colbert Report go >>
  • John Luther Adams profiled on Grist.org go >>
  • Arne Duncan writes profile of Salman Khan for Vanity Fair go >>
  • David Heymann is interviewed on CNN about the Ebola vaccine go >>
  • John Holdren discusses climate change with David Letterman go >>
  • Ralph Cavanagh writes Op-Ed on energy for The New York Times go >>
  • Dave Eggers has a new short story in The New Yorker go >>
  • Geoffrey Canada shares Bowdoin College’s highest honor, The Bowdoin Prize go >>
  • Jane Lubchenco is interviewed by Yale Environment 360 go >>
  • James Nachtwey photographs veterans at Walter Reed, for Time go >>
  • John Luther Adams named 2015 Composer of the Year by Musical America Worldwide go >>
  • Abraham Verghese writes on Treating Ebola Without Fear in The New York Times Magazine go >>
  • The Guardian interviews David Heymann on a podcast about the Ebola epidemic go >>
  • Bruce Katz writes on "How universities can renew America's cities," in Fortune go >>
  • Leila Janah spoke at Forbes' inaugural Under 30 Summit on her crowdfunding effort, Samahope go >>
  • Hugh Herr receives the 2014 American Ingenuity Award in Tech from The Smithsonian Institution go >>
  • Jane Lubchenco to receive 2014 Stephen H. Schneider Award for Outstanding Climate Science Communication go >>
  • Bernice Johnson Reagon headlines Baylor University panel on preserving black sacred music go >>
  • The Harlem Children's Zone headquarters will be renamed the Geoffrey Canada Community Center go >>
  • Rita Dove returns to her hometown of Akron for a literacy event go >>
  • Rita Dove wins the Carole Weinstein Prize in Poetry at the 17th Annual Library of Virginia Literary Awards go >>
  • Dave Eggers interviewed by Detroit-based Model D Media go >>
  • Paul Farmer writes about his first-hand experiences surveying the Ebola outbreaks in Africa go >>
  • Harvard Gazette writes about Paul Farmer's Partners In Health confronting ebola in Liberia and Sierra Leone go >>
  • Brenda Eheart's Generations of Hope part of article by Newsweek on multigenerational communities go >>
  • James Balog, 3rd recipient of Dickinson College’s Rose-Walters prize, is profiled by The Sentinel go >>
  • Freeman Hrabowski speaks about his personal history and issues of diversity at Colorado State University go >>
  • TIME celebrates 30 years of James Nachtwey's photography for the magazine go >>
  • Rick Lowe is awarded a 2014 MacArthur fellowship go >>
  • Paul Farmer working on care facility in Liberia to aid ebola patients go >>
  • Abraham Verghese gives TEDMED talk on how he draws from the language of metaphors as a doctor and author go >>
  • Marian Wright Edelman urges states to do more for rural poor children in Huffington Post piece go >>
  • Mason Bates' orchestral piece, Alternative Energy, is reviewed in the San Francisco Chronicle go >>
  • Jay Keasling receives the 2014 Economist Innovation Award for Bioscience go >>
  • Sidney Drell co-authors new book on nuclear security go >>
  • Sam Nunn co-authors new book on nuclear security go >>
  • Robert Berkebile selected as 2014 recipient of The Hanley Award for Vision and Leadership in Sustainability go >>
  • President of The World Bank, Jim Kim, posts thoughts on a conversation with Salman Khan go >>
  • Sanjeev Arora brings Project ECHO to India go >>
  • Amory Lovins argues that we can reduce fossil fuel use 80 percent with existing technology go >>
  • Scientists You Must Know, from the Chemical Heritage Foundation, presents a short documentary on Robert Langer's life and work go >>
  • Salman Khan writes for Huffington Post on the importance of struggle and mistakes in learning go >>
  • Business Insider profiles Hugh Herr and his evolution from rock climber to bionics inventor go >>
  • Katie Couric talks to Dean Kamen about his 'Luke' prosthetic arm, for Yahoo! News go >>
  • Nancy Knowlton shares her views on the health and future of coral reefs on the Diane Rehm Show go >>
  • Kirk Smith pens editorial for Science on bringing electricity to those who do not have it go >>
  • The premiere of John Luther Adams' "Sila - The Breath of the World" is reviewed in The New York Times go >>
  • Bruce Katz co-authors an article on "A year later, what cities can learn from Detroit's bankruptcy," in Fortune go >>
  • Dean Kamen talks to ZD Net about FIRST, turning innovation into a competition, and why failure is a critical part of the formula for success go >>
  • Leila Janah is interviewed about Samasource on ReadWrite.com go >>
  • Forbes takes a look at Dean Kamen’s Stirling Engine go >>
  • Christopher Field to receive the Roger Revelle Medal from the American Geophysical Union go >>

The Heinz Awards

2002

George Lee Butler

George Lee Butler receives the Heinz Award for Public Policy for the clarity of his vision about the risks and dangers of nuclear weapons, for the courage with which he expressed and implemented it, and for the impact that he has had on the way in which the United States and the world view nuclear weapons in the post-Cold War period.

Virtually single-handedly, and at personal risk to his own career, General Butler questioned whether large numbers of nuclear weapons were needed for national defense, and inspired politicians, military officers, academics and ordinary citizens to re-examine their views and reassess their priorities.

George Lee Butler's early career as a young Air Force Academy graduate established what soon became a characteristic blend of intellect and action. After finishing first in flight school, he studied international relations at the University of Paris. In 1968, after volunteering to lead F-4 fighter missions in Vietnam, he spent a further six months as aide to the commander of the war's air operations.

In 1974, he was assigned to the Air Force's Directorate of Plans at the Pentagon, and was called upon to help prepare positions on the upcoming U.S. - Soviet Strategic Arms Limitation Talks (SALT). To his surprise - and dismay - he discovered that many of the controversies surrounding the Soviet nuclear threat were based as much on bureaucratic politics as on hardheaded assessments of strategic vulnerability. As he became increasingly privy to the highest reaches of strategic planning, he became increasingly skeptical about its underlying rationale.

In 1991, named as commander of the Strategic Air Command (SAC), General Butler assumed control of some 5,700 deployed nuclear warheads. Appalled to find that many of the sites marked as nuclear targets still reflected the overkill strategies of the Cold War era, General Butler revised the list, eliminating thousands of sites, and creating new strike options that involved using nuclear weapons against only a small number of targets.

Having recommended and planned for the closure of SAC in 1992, General Butler remained to head its much-reduced successor, the Strategic Command (STRATCOM). On the eve of the resumed U.S. - Russian START II arms talks, he urged the negotiators to adopt lower ceilings of nuclear weapons. Many observers felt that General Butler's active, open and articulate advocacy for arms limitations contributed to his being passed over as General Colin Powell's successor as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

General Butler's retirement from the military in 1994, after 33 years of service, marked the beginning of a new and more public career of commitment to rethinking the role of nuclear weapons. He was invited by the Australian government to be a member of the Canberra Commission, studying the feasibility of abolishing nuclear weapons. In a series of public statements, beginning with a major speech at the National Press Club in 1996, he called for the outright abolition of nuclear weapons. In 1999, he and his wife founded the Second Chance Foundation, dedicated to promoting responsible global reduction of nuclear dangers.

Despite the fact that his beliefs were frequently not in keeping with official policy, congruent with professional bias or conducive to personal advancement, George Lee Butler has been willing to take the risks required to do what he felt was right. He has made the world a better place by drastically decreasing the numbers of, and the planned uses for, nuclear weapons.

Note: This profile is excerpted from the commemorative brochure published at the time of the awards' presentation.

Speech

3/12/2002 - Acceptance Speech

Thank you, and good evening ladies and gentlemen. You do me great honor this evening. I feel especially privileged to be among such a distinguished group of honorees. On behalf of myself and my family I thank the Heinz Foundation for this affirmation of a quest spanning over a quarter-century: to help walk mankind back from the brink of nuclear self-destruction.

While this quest is not unique to me, it was, as the Foundation noted, surely unique for me to undertake such a role. It is not one that came easily nor readily. My sense of urgency and obligation grew in proportion to my access to classified information, my exposure to the risks of military operations and my alarm at the unbridled appetite for sustaining or acquiring nuclear arsenals notwithstanding the end of the Cold War.

Nor, as you also observed, is it a role easily played. While not surprised, I was nonetheless bemused by the reaction to my views, which ranged from condemnation to adulation. I discovered following my speech to the National Press Club in late 1996 that it is indeed possible to become simultaneously an icon and an iconoclast. On one memorable day, I received both a scathing rebuke from a former colleague, and a letter informing me I had been selected Sweetheart of the Year by the Grandmothers for Peace. I was immediately reminded of Harry Truman's advice to "always tell the truth - half your audience will be astonished and the other half gratified."

Breaking ranks in the nuclear weapons arena is risky business, not so much because of state secrets but because truth is so much in the eye of the beholder. It is a world of sweeping assertions and heroic assumptions, taken largely on faith, which if proved wrong would have apocalyptic consequences. But, for me, over time, a compelling truth emerged, the product of too many crises born of human frailty and the failure of both men and machines. Today, as the delicate balance of Cold War terror is better understood, and we witness the willing brinksmanship of new nuclear antagonists, this truth is starkly evident: we human beings are not to be trusted with the capacity for such boundless, wanton destructiveness. Our appetites, our egos, our fears and our enmities stand all too ready to brush aside the cautions of deterrence and to eagerly brandish the nuclear saber.

Yet, there is reason for hope. In this country, I see greater recognition that nuclear weapons are an affront to civilized norms, that a single such device poses an intolerable threat, and that the United States has both a moral and a security imperative to loosen their grip on our safety and our humanity. After a prolonged period of dismay, I am modestly heartened by recent events. The Bush administration has approached the task of reducing nuclear dangers with conviction and the promise of concrete results. While critics may quarrel over the detail of the Nuclear Posture Review, its direction is encouraging: fewer delivery systems, less reliance on offensive deterrence, and a greater focus on threatening capabilities rather than preconceived enemies. Over time, that will translate into less relevance, more secure postures and even greater antipathy for these ultimate weapons of mass destruction.

In closing, let me underscore my admiration for Senator John Heinz, and for this extraordinary program you have created to preserve and expand his legacy. I know he would understand the motivation and the purpose of my quest. I have only to consider the goodness of my wife, the shining integrity of our children and the wondrous innocence of our grandchildren to know where my obligation lies. May God bless you and our great nation in its quest to rid the world of terror in all of its forms.
George Lee Butler
George Lee Butler